A Evidence based guidelines - the evidence base for mammography in breast inflammation
Breast Inflammation
| A |
Clinical Problem |
Breast Inflammation |
|
| A1 |
Ref No. in MBUR4 (if any) |
J13 |
|
| A2 |
Section in MBUR4 |
Breast disease |
|
| B |
Search strategy: databases used; period; MeSH headings; other key words. |
Medline 1966-June 2001, EMBASE 1988-2001, diagnostic imaging, breast disease, abscess, radiography, ultrasonography |
|
| C |
Search results: no. found; no. used. |
37 found, 2 used |
|
| D |
Reference numbers of cited references in attached master list. |
J13 1,2 |
|
| E |
Summarised results from each of the cited references |
Crowe et al (J13 1) reviewed records of 21 women having imaging within 48 hours of presenting with breast inflammation. 63% of mammograms were abnormal. Diffuse skin thickening, oedema and dense lymph nodes suggest unusual infection or malignancy. All 11 ultrasounds showed heterogeneous masses with internal echoes, 5 of these inpatients with normal mammograms. Muttarak (J13 2) reports mammography and ultrasound in 20 abscesses, the combination allowed recognition of infection and helped to exclude malignancy. |
|
| F |
Statement (= the conclusion drawn from E) |
Mammography helps to diagnose or exclude malignancy when there is clinical doubt, Ultrasound is the examination of first choice and can guide drainage. |
|
| G |
Evidence level of F classified I - IV |
3 |
|
| H |
Investigation |
Mammography |
|
| I |
Recommendation * |
Specialised examination |
|
| J |
Grade of Recommendation A - C |
C |
|
| K |
Comment (if any) to go in booklet version of MBUR5 |
||
| L |
Any other comments on this problem (e.g. caveats; suggestions for research or systematic review; cost or opportunity cost; users' views. |
Ros Given-Wilson |
Comments: Early surgical consultation advised
References: -
| Ref ID | Author; Year; Country; Grade (I-IV). | Aims | Patient population | Study design* | Results |
| J13 1 | Crowe D et al, 1995, USA, III | Review of imaging in 21 women with breast infection | 21 women age 13-69 presenting consecutively with breast infection and undergoing breast imaging within 48 hours of presentation | Retrospective series | All having US showed abscesses even when the mammograms were normal. Mammograms were abnormal in 63%, showing masses and asymmetries in most. Diffuse skin thickening, oedema and dense nodes were rare and indicative of unusual infection or malignancy. |
| J13 2 | Muttarak M | Review of breast imaging in abscesses in non lactating breasts | 20 patients presenting with lump and/or pain without other clinical signs of inflammation and found to have abscesses | Retrospective series | Mammography commonly showed ill defined masses or asymmetries and US showed abscesses. |
* e.g. RCT Comparison (pro/retro-spective)
Series (pro/retro-spective)
Audit